148 lines
6.9 KiB
Plaintext
148 lines
6.9 KiB
Plaintext
F1 Plan Compliance Audit
|
|
|
|
Timestamp: 2026-03-02 20:59:50
|
|
Plan: /Users/thorsten/AI/cts/.sisyphus/plans/cts-round5-features.md
|
|
Codebase (verification target): /Users/thorsten/AI/cts-work
|
|
Evidence output: .sisyphus/evidence/f1-compliance-audit.txt
|
|
|
|
Repo State
|
|
- /Users/thorsten/AI/cts HEAD b6739b9e6d0b9cc79b37ea74910ef9216ebcf7fa (dirty)
|
|
- /Users/thorsten/AI/cts-work HEAD 6e48779259832674f49bf70c3962ccd06c9aada4 (dirty)
|
|
|
|
Verification Commands (Plan lines 1173-1189)
|
|
1) php -d memory_limit=512M artisan test --exclude-group=oom
|
|
Result: PASS (198 tests passed, 0 failed)
|
|
|
|
2) npm run build
|
|
Result: PASS (vite build succeeded)
|
|
|
|
3) php artisan schedule:list 2>&1 | grep cts:sync
|
|
Result: PASS
|
|
Output: 0 * * * * php artisan cts:sync
|
|
|
|
4) php -r "require 'vendor/autoload.php'; echo class_exists('ProPresenter\Parser\ProFileReader') ? 'OK' : 'FAIL';"
|
|
Result: PASS (OK)
|
|
|
|
Must Have (Plan lines 84-89)
|
|
1) All 7 items fully implemented and working: FAIL
|
|
- Fetch next 10 services: fetchEvents() currently returns up to 20 (10 past + 10 future)
|
|
Evidence: /Users/thorsten/AI/cts-work/app/Services/ChurchToolsService.php:193-196
|
|
|
|
2) ProPresenter .pro import/export functional: PASS
|
|
- Import controller: /Users/thorsten/AI/cts-work/app/Http/Controllers/ProFileController.php:14-48
|
|
- Import service: /Users/thorsten/AI/cts-work/app/Services/ProImportService.php:19-170
|
|
- Export service: /Users/thorsten/AI/cts-work/app/Services/ProExportService.php:10-83
|
|
|
|
3) Playlist export for finalized services: PASS (function exists and is tested)
|
|
- Download endpoint: /Users/thorsten/AI/cts-work/app/Http/Controllers/ServiceController.php:269-289
|
|
|
|
4) All German UI text (Du, not Sie): PASS (spot-check)
|
|
- No formal "Sie" found via search in app/resources.
|
|
Note: UI uses the term "Services" in several places; treat as accepted loanword unless strict policy disallows it.
|
|
|
|
5) Immediate persistence (no save buttons): FAIL
|
|
- Found explicit save button:
|
|
Evidence: /Users/thorsten/AI/cts-work/resources/js/Pages/Songs/Translate.vue:251-259
|
|
|
|
Must Have tally: 3/5
|
|
|
|
Must NOT Have (Guardrails, Plan lines 91-100)
|
|
1) NO .pro browser editor or viewer: PASS
|
|
- No editor libs (monaco/codemirror) found in resources/js.
|
|
|
|
2) NO media file embedding in playlists (songs only): FAIL
|
|
- Playlist export embeds slide images (media=...)
|
|
Evidence: /Users/thorsten/AI/cts-work/app/Services/PlaylistExportService.php:155-158
|
|
|
|
3) NO full HTTP response body logging (use existing summary): FAIL
|
|
- API log stores serialized response_body (up to 512KB) and UI fetches/displays it
|
|
Evidence:
|
|
/Users/thorsten/AI/cts-work/app/Services/ChurchToolsService.php:221-229
|
|
/Users/thorsten/AI/cts-work/app/Services/ChurchToolsService.php:269-281
|
|
/Users/thorsten/AI/cts-work/app/Http/Controllers/ApiLogController.php:44-50
|
|
/Users/thorsten/AI/cts-work/resources/js/Pages/ApiLogs/Index.vue:92-110
|
|
|
|
4) NO chunked uploads, retry logic, or upload cancellation: PASS (spot-check)
|
|
- Upload uses single axios.post() per file, no resumable/chunk logic.
|
|
Evidence: /Users/thorsten/AI/cts-work/resources/js/Components/SlideUploader.vue:53-131
|
|
|
|
5) NO configurable schedule frequency UI: PASS
|
|
- Scheduling is defined in bootstrap/app.php only.
|
|
Evidence: /Users/thorsten/AI/cts-work/bootstrap/app.php:18-20
|
|
|
|
6) NO sync comparison or per-service sync: PASS (no code found)
|
|
|
|
7) NO batch .pro export UI: PASS
|
|
- Only per-song download and per-service playlist download exist.
|
|
|
|
8) NO ProPresenter library source modifications: PASS (best-effort)
|
|
- No copied ProPresenter namespaces outside vendor.
|
|
- Composer uses path repository.
|
|
Evidence: /Users/thorsten/AI/cts-work/composer.json:8-26
|
|
|
|
9) NO CTS API writes (READONLY only): PASS (best-effort)
|
|
- No CTApi write methods found; ChurchToolsService uses EventRequest/SongRequest reads.
|
|
|
|
Must NOT Have tally: 7/9
|
|
|
|
Tasks vs Acceptance Criteria (Plan Tasks T1-T10)
|
|
T1 ProPresenter composer integration: PASS
|
|
- Evidence: /Users/thorsten/AI/cts-work/composer.json:8-26 + autoload check OK
|
|
|
|
T2 CTS event ID tooltip: PASS
|
|
- Backend mapping includes cts_event_id: /Users/thorsten/AI/cts-work/app/Http/Controllers/ServiceController.php:62-77
|
|
- Frontend title attribute: /Users/thorsten/AI/cts-work/resources/js/Pages/Services/Index.vue:300-302
|
|
|
|
T3 Hourly scheduler: PASS
|
|
- /Users/thorsten/AI/cts-work/bootstrap/app.php:18-20
|
|
|
|
T4 Archived toggle highlight: PASS
|
|
- /Users/thorsten/AI/cts-work/resources/js/Pages/Services/Index.vue:26
|
|
|
|
T5 Limit CTS fetch to next 10 services: FAIL
|
|
- fetchEvents merges 10 past + 10 future => up to 20
|
|
/Users/thorsten/AI/cts-work/app/Services/ChurchToolsService.php:193-196
|
|
|
|
T6 API log expandable request/response detail rows: FAIL (scope/guardrail mismatch)
|
|
- Plan expects request_context + response_summary, not full response_body.
|
|
- Current UI loads and renders response_body.
|
|
/Users/thorsten/AI/cts-work/resources/js/Pages/ApiLogs/Index.vue:92-110
|
|
/Users/thorsten/AI/cts-work/resources/js/Pages/ApiLogs/Index.vue:208-219
|
|
|
|
T7 Drag'n'drop auto-upload + JSON error fix: PASS
|
|
- watch(files) auto-triggers upload + axios multipart
|
|
/Users/thorsten/AI/cts-work/resources/js/Components/SlideUploader.vue:53-131
|
|
|
|
T8 .pro import: PASS
|
|
- /Users/thorsten/AI/cts-work/app/Services/ProImportService.php
|
|
|
|
T9 .pro export: PASS
|
|
- /Users/thorsten/AI/cts-work/app/Services/ProExportService.php
|
|
|
|
T10 Finalized service .proplaylist export: FAIL (scope/guardrail mismatch)
|
|
- Route differs from plan (uses /services/{service}/download, not /download-playlist)
|
|
/Users/thorsten/AI/cts-work/routes/web.php:58
|
|
- Exports include slide presentations and embedded JPG media, violating "songs only" playlist rule
|
|
/Users/thorsten/AI/cts-work/app/Services/PlaylistExportService.php:35-83
|
|
/Users/thorsten/AI/cts-work/app/Services/PlaylistExportService.php:137-195
|
|
- Skipped songs are only signaled via header, not a flash warning as specified
|
|
/Users/thorsten/AI/cts-work/app/Http/Controllers/ServiceController.php:281-283
|
|
- Temp cleanup is not performed (deleteFileAfterSend(false), temp_dir returned)
|
|
/Users/thorsten/AI/cts-work/app/Http/Controllers/ServiceController.php:279-286
|
|
/Users/thorsten/AI/cts-work/app/Services/PlaylistExportService.php:96-101
|
|
|
|
Tasks tally: 7/10
|
|
|
|
Evidence Files Check (.sisyphus/evidence/ in /Users/thorsten/AI/cts)
|
|
- Present: task-1-*.txt, task-2-test-results.txt, task-3-*.txt, task-4-build.txt, task-5-test-results.txt, task-6-* (png/txt)
|
|
- Missing for this plan: task-7-*, task-8-*, task-9-*, task-10-* evidence files
|
|
|
|
Output Format (Plan line 1138)
|
|
Must Have [3/5] | Must NOT Have [7/9] | Tasks [7/10] | VERDICT: REJECT
|
|
|
|
Primary Reject Reasons
|
|
- Playlist export embeds non-song media (slides/JPG) and therefore violates "songs only" guardrail.
|
|
- API logs persist and expose response_body (full-ish serialized response), violating "no full response body logging".
|
|
- CTS fetch is not limited to the next 10 services (returns up to 20: past+future).
|
|
- Immediate persistence requirement violated by explicit Save button (translation page).
|